Friday, September 25, 2009

Roger Cohen Again Demonizes Israel: No Slip of the Pen

A few thoughts about Roger Cohen's latest New York Times op-ed re Germany, "The Miracles of Dullness". His penultimate paragraph:

"The demon [italics added] of instability, German-prodded, moved to the Middle East, where another modern nation state, Israel, in turn upended the order of things. Perhaps after 74 years (1871-1945), we will see glimmerings of a new, more peaceful regional order there. Hope is almost as stubborn as facts."

First, is this right or wrong? Answer: This is absurd. There have been innumerable wars and insurrections since the establishment of the State of Israel involving the various Arab countries and Iran that did not involve Israel in any way whatsoever. Moreover, these wars resulted in an exponentially larger number of civilian and non-civilian casualties than all of the Arab/Israeli wars combined:

1. The Syrian invasion of Jordan in 1970 in support of the Palestinian attempt to overthrow the Jordanian government.
2. Black September. The PLO sought to overthrow the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, which constitutes 77% of the original Palestine mandate.
3. The Lebanese Civil War from 1975 to 1990, which resulted from ethnic tensions and changing demographics favoring Lebanon's Shiites.
4. Iraq-Kuwait clashes in 1973, 1976 and 1990. Iraq claimed Kuwait as part of Iraq.
5. The Iran-Iraq War, which lasted for eight years and resulted in the deaths of at least half a million combatants and non-combatants.
6. The Dhofar Rebellion, 1962-1975.
7. The 1963 Sand War between Morocco and Algeria.
8. The 1973 Libya-Chad War.
9. The 1977 Libya-Egypt War.
10. The Western Sahara conflict involving Morocco and Algeria in the 1970s.
11. The ongoing Somali Civil War.
12. The First and Second Sudanese Civil Wars.
13. The genocide in Darfur.
14. The North Yemen Civil War.
15. The 1994 Civil War in Yemen.
16. The 2004-2007 Sa'dah Conflict.

And let's not forget the Kurdish uprisings against Iraq and Iran, the barbarities perpetrated against Iran's Baha'is, and the Syrian army's 1982 bombardment of Hama to quell a revolt by the Muslim Brotherhood, which resulted in the deaths of up to 40,000 people.

Of course, Cohen is free to write whatever he pleases, correct or incorrect, and much of what he wrote about Iran has been widely discredited. In this vein, I would only add that although I was promised by the Public Editor's office of The New York Times that I would receive an answer whether Cohen's "What Iran's Jews Say" was in keeping with New York Times' standards of journalistic ethics, they have since refused to honor their commitment. Jill Abramson also has refused to touch this issue.

Far more serious is Cohen's latest link between Israel and Nazi Germany, albeit indirect, in an op-ed having nothing to do with Israel. This is much in keeping with the anti-Semitic connotations involving the title of Cohen's earlier op-ed, "Obama in Netanyahu's Web".

The New York Times wishes to publish this? It's The Times' prerogative, but I think The Times need also consider the resulting enmity and anti-Semitism, which in no way contribute to understanding or peace.

Cohen would have us believe that Israel is also a "demon of instability". After his farcical series of op-eds on Iran which went unchecked by The Times, we can only wonder about the demons floating around Cohen's head.

4 comments:

  1. Jeffrey:

    How do you understand, why Cohen hates Israel? I am very curious to know your view on it. It seems, there is something personal on his part, do not you think so?

    Also, I read your yesterday comments on the Friedman's column. It seems contradictory to me. In the first paragraph, you say that the problem is not that intractable. In the second paragraph, you explain that the problem is in the high birth rate of Palestinians. So, what may be a solution?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Marina,

    If you haven't done so already, watch Cohen at Sinai Temple, attempting to explain his Iran op-eds to Iranian Jews and Baha'is:

    http://www.jewishjournal.com/videojew/item/live_video_tonight_a_dialogue_with_roger_cohen_and_the_iranian_jewish_commu/

    Something personal? Very. I'm sure you know that I invited him to visit Israel, and offered to take him to Sderot, to see the miracles of Israeli biotech, and to learn a bit about the history of Caesarea. Although he said he was interested, he never came. Why didn't he come? What is he afraid he might discover about himself?

    Solutions to the Israeli/Palestinian conflict? I believe that any solution must be based upon economics, i.e. when Palestinians understand there is nothing gained by blowing themselves up, yet every reason to live and prosper by integrating their economy with that of Israel.

    High birth rates are indeed part of the problem. Note the average birth rates of Israeli Arabs, West Bank Palestinians and Gazan Palestinians. Now observe the economic status and relative radicalism of these three sectors.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I just saw the video the first time. I do not think it explains anything about Cohen's hatred. The guy is pathetic and hypocritical as his columns.
    I wonder, why would you even want to meet this guy! He does not care about truth. After meeting with Jews from Iran he has nerve to tell them that there is no anti-semitism!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Cohen is "hypocritical"? I think you're being kind.

    The invitation was made before the Iranian op-eds. It no longer stands.

    ReplyDelete